When it comes to any type of fashion item (whether it’s clothing, swimwear, bags, or shoes), there’s a fine line between something feeling underwhelmingly basic and overly trendy that’s often hard to get close to, let alone touch on. Luckily, as your own personal shoppers, here at Who What Wear, we’re kind of experts at it—and our namesake clothing and accessory collections reflect it, too.

That’s why—with relative ease—today I’m able to bring you a whopping twenty-five summer footwear options (including flat sandals, heels, and mules)—all of which not only hit on that perfect in-between mark of trendy but not too trendy. They also happen to cost under $100, too. In short, you can pick up a new pair for this season sans guilt, knowing you won’t get sick of it by the time next summer rolls around. To see and shop all the pretty styles for yourself, just keep scrolling.

The best thing about these blue sandals is how good they look paired with other colors.

Block-heel sandals are my go-to’s for comfortable height.

I’m very into white sandals lately, almost more than the nudes of season’s past.

Silver is another less-common neutral that actually goes with everything.

Date night in, anyone?

These barely there kitten heels will become your new go-to’s.

Every wardrobe needs one pop of pink.

For ultra long-looking legs.

Classic.

It’s hard for me to resist anything in this color.

A pair of classic sandals in an of-the-moment color.

Everything looks chicer in snake print.

Swap your plastic black flip-flops for a leather-look pair.

Cross-strap mules are another comfortable option I highly recommend.

Fashion girls are all about fancy flip-flops.

The quintessential summer mules.

If you’re bored of basic ballet flats, give these a try.

The square-shaped back on these makes a subtle statement.

Buckles give slide sandals a fancy element that makes you feel like you can wear them almost anywhere.

Speaking of fancy…

These sandals have been popular with our editors and fashion girls alike.

Go-with-anything slides.

I have these in black and have been living in them over the past couple months.

Lighten up any look with this white pair.

You can never go wrong with a pair of strappy black sandals.

Next, I’m a picky shopper and this is what I’d buy from Nordstrom for summer.