If there’s one thing we know for certain, it’s that there is no shortage of lash-enhancing products setting up shop in the beauty industry. Between serums, primers, mascaras, falsies, and almost every other kind of elixir you can think of, people are obsessed with getting the long and fluttery lashes of their dreams. As with most things in the beauty realm, certain formulas are much better (not to mention safer) than others. If you’ve been wondering how to grow your eyelashes to their full potential, you’re most certainly living in the right era, but some guidance as to the newest, best-selling, or top-rated serums can be helpful. (Not to scare you, but Amazon currently has 14 pages of offerings—eek!)

Also worth noting? There is only one FDA-approved formula (ahem, prescription-grade Latisse) consented to encourage lash growth. As for all the other tubes, combs, and potions, they’re loaded with lots of amazing ingredients that can arm your lashes against breakage and damage. In other words, they can help make a sparse or dehydrated lash line healthier overall. If you’ve been wondering how to grow your eyelashes using the latest, greatest, best-selling formulas, you’ve come to the right place. Ahead, we’re highlighting the top three eyelash serums from Amazon, Sephora, and Dermstore, including blurbs from their A+ reviews. Keep scrolling!

Number of customer reviews: 503. Average rating: 4.5/5. Fortified with luxe botanicals and two pro-keratin peptides, this vegan eyelash serum is a top pick from Amazon’s seriously overwhelming collection. Plus, you can also feel free to swipe it on your brows. “This stuff works great on my lashes,” says Amazon customer Karen. “It took about six weeks to take effect, but my lashes are now long enough that they sometimes brush against my sunglasses.”

Number of customer reviews: 14,030. Average rating: 4.5/5. This fan-favorite lash serum is one of the most popular formulas living the dark depths of Amazon, and it’s no wonder considering its impressive ingredient makeup. Think peptides, Panax ginseng extract, Swertia japonica extract, hyaluronic acid, and biotin to boot.  “Before trying Lavish Lash, I had tried another (much more expensive) product with ‘meh’ results,” explains one Amazon reviewer. “I researched other options on Amazon and settled on this one. Good reviews, reasonable priced, why not…I’ve been using it for two months now and OMG…its legit. I look like I wear fake eyelashes, and I LOVE it! I have used it religiously every night before I go to bed and I could probably go down to one time every other night…but I’m kind of enjoying having ridiculously long lashes.”

Number of customer reviews: 2124. Average rating: 3.5/5. You can find this best-selling eyelash serum at all the best beauty retailers, from Amazon to Sephora to Ulta, and it consistently receives super-impressive ratings. It’s enriched with vitamins, peptides, and amino acids and is said to encourage a longer- and thicker-looking flutter in as little as four to six months.  Here’s what Amazon customer Kristin had to say: “This stuff is a miracle product. I rarely write reviews, but I really was compelled to because I LOVE this product. I started seeing results after two or three weeks, but now, after consistently using it daily for three months, I have eyelashes that look false or like extensions! I am beyond pleased. My eyelashes used to be short, sparse, and I was missing lashes on each corner of the eye. Not only did it make them thicker, but it also made them grow back in the corners. They are SO long my son told me today I may have to cut them at some point because they are almost touching my eyebrows. Lol” Um, adorable. 

Number of customer reviews: 187. Average rating: 4/5. FYI: This new eyelash serum from beloved skincare brand Peter Thomas Roth is already making waves within the industry. It’s fortified with an 11% peptide complex with biotin in addition to a 10% conditioning complex and other ingredients like Tahitian plankton extract. Not to mention it’s ophthalmologist-tested and free of icky things like sulfates SLS and SLES, parabens, formaldehyde, formaldehyde-releasing agents, phthalates, mineral oil, oxybenzone, coal tar, hydroquinone, triclosan, and triclocarban. “I’ve really enjoyed using this product over the last few weeks and have definitely seen a difference in the thickness of my lashes,” explains one Sephora reviewer. “The serum is easy to apply, and it works overnight. If you’re looking for a way to enhance your natural lashes without having to spend tons of money on extensions, this is a great product!”

Number of customer reviews: 281. Average rating: 4.5/5. Milk Makeup is one of the coolest makeup-and-skincare brands in the biz right now, and its epic cannabis-infused line called Kush is top-rated proof. The newest addition? This epic brow-and-lash serum, which has hemp-derived cannabis seed extract, yes, but also quinoa and peptides for an extra dose of nourishment. It’s brand new, but here’s what people are saying on Sephora’s website thus far: “I’ve been using it for about a week! I have sensitive eyes and no stinging or tearing! So far, the results are softer brow hairs and lashes that definitely feel conditioned! Would recommend if you’re looking for a product like this!”

Number of customer reviews: 368. Average rating: 4/5. Lashfood makes some of the most well-known lash-enhancing formulas, and this serum, in particular, is one of the best if you’ve been wondering how to effortlessly grow and improve the health of your lashes. The serum features the brand’s Phyto-Medic Complex alongside its Eyelash Enhancing System, which delivers nutrients directly to your lashes. It’s also Ecocert-certified, dermatologist-tested and -approved, and vegan. One happy Sephora customer said, “Love this product! This product is great. It definitely made my lashes stronger, longer, fuller, and healthier. I started seeing a bit of a change after about two to three months of use, but I really, truly noticed a very significant change after many more months. I’ve now been using it for about a year, and my eyelashes are clearly longer and fuller—just overall healthier!”

Number of customer reviews: 557. Average rating: 5/5. Brimming with lash-healthy ingredients like copper peptides, biotin, hyaluronic acid, peptides, and panthenol, Raid Lash is specifically formulated to improve the length, thickness, and volume of lashes while simultaneously guarding against unwanted damage and breakage. Plus, it’s extra hydrating to enhance shine and softness. “This product works and seems to be more than half the price of similar products!” explains one Dermstore customer. “I use it every night on my eyelashes and now get frequent compliments on the length of my lashes. I’ve been using the product for several months now, and it took about three to four weeks to notice any difference. One tube lasts me about five to six weeks.”

Number of customer reviews: 3730. Average rating: 5/5. We like to think the perfect five-star rating, 3000 and counting reviews, and under-$50 price tag do all the talking for you, but for those wondering how to grow your eyelashes, listen up. The formula is non-irritating and chock-full of lash-lengthening ingredients like biotin, peptides, and panthenol. Plus, it’s also great to swipe on sparse brows as well. “I can’t get over how well this product actually works!” dotes one Dermstore customer. “After several weeks of regular use, I noticed my eyelashes were really getting longer! I felt like I was in a mascara ad. It was amazing! Highly recommend!”

Number of customer reviews: 81. Average rating: 5/5. Unfortunately, many eyelash serums can be irritating, and it’s really one of those categories of beauty products that might take some trial and error. That said, this clinically tested serum from NeuLash is great for those wanting to better their lash line and is known for being less irritating. One of the less-expected superstar ingredients? Pumpkin seed extract. In fact, one ecstatic reviewer on Dermstore touted the formula as a “miracle product”: “I had an unfortunate mishap with my eyelash curler five years ago and accidentally removed all of my lashes from the inner part (near my nose) to about a quarter of the way out along the lash line. I thought I’d have a ‘bald’ area on my eye forever, but then I found this product. It not only grew back my lashes (thank GOD!) but it gave me the longest and most beautiful lashes I’ve ever had. Will always repurchase!”

Number of customer reviews: 6. Average rating: 4.8/5. If you liked Vegamour’s original Gro formula, then you’ll love this new version enhanced with full-spectrum hemp oil. This powerful, plant-based serum also includes mung bean and red clover to help promote new growth and stronger, thicker lashes.  One reviewer notes, “I don’t even use this every day and have seen a significant difference after three months… I saw changes as early as one month. Longer and fuller lashes!”

Number of customer reviews: 348. Average rating: 4.4/5. Ever wonder how Meghan Markle maintains her megawatt lashes? She might have this serum to thank (and her makeup artist, Daniel Martin, for turning her on to it).  In fact, a reviewer on Nordstrom shares, “I bought this after I heard Meghan Markle raving it about it. IT WORKS. And this is coming from someone who never has any product work. I started seeing results about a month and a half of CONSISTENT, daily use.”  

Number of customer reviews: 0 Average rating: N/A. This new, natural formula includes peptides, biotin, and folic acid to energize and condition your lashes, extend the life of each follicle, and prevent thinning. As with all HydroPeptide products, hyaluronic acid provides lightweight moisture which helps to minimize breakage.

This article was originally published at an earlier date and has been updated. Up next, 14 (Actually) Effective Products for Hair Growth, According to Amazon Reviews.