Despite the array of goodies I discover while online shopping, sometimes I get stumped and can’t find that perfect piece—like now. I’ve been on the hunt for four fall essentials: a cozy loungewear set, a good jacket that doesn’t cost an arm and a leg, a cute sweater, and a new pair of jeans. Sure, there are plenty of nice items I’ve come across, but nothing has swayed me enough to actually make a purchase. (I’m picky, so sue me.) That is, until recently, when my Amazon search led me to the jackpot, and now I’m over here just trying not to buy everything. Under-$100 coats? Yep. An affordable knit cardigan? Mhm. One of those matching tie-dye sets? Duh. And my personal favorite: skinny jeans you’d never guess were only $27. Keep scrolling to see the pieces currently at top of mind.

Up Next: Psst: Fall’s Cutest Shoes and Accessories Are Hiding on Amazon.