We, the fashion editors at Who What Wear, simply can’t get enough of J.Crew right now. The collections have been top-notch with Olympia Gayot at the helm of womenswear. Given the adoration of the brand in general, I thought I’d ask my fellow fashion editors about the specific new fall J.Crew items they love the most. 

Below you’ll uncover the editor-approved fall items in question. As a preview, you’ll notice everything from gorgeous knitwear to beautiful jackets that have the power to become new wardrobe staples. Oh, there’s also a curation of standout shoes and accessories.

Keep scrolling to check out the best fall items from J.Crew.

“Is it just me or do these J.Crew tweed jackets just get better and better?” — Allyson Payer, senior fashion editor

“I noticed a lot of ’70s inspiration on the J.Crew site right now and I’m so here for it. I feel like every fall, that aesthetic rises up to the plate and a pair of flared jeans is a must-have for fashion people. I’m buying this pair first.” — Sierra Mayhew, associate fashion editor

“Mary-Jane flats are a standout trend this season and square-toe designs are high on my list, especially in a classic black like this pair.” — Jennifer Camp Forbes, shopping updates editor

“It’s hard to find the perfect trench coat, but this one checks all the boxes for me.” — Allyson Payer, senior fashion editor

“Add a bold cuff like this to just about any outfit, simple or not, to take it to new heights.” — Anna LaPlaca, editor

“The thing that I’m most excited to wear this fall, is sweater sets. I love layering up and I know for a fact that I’ll be cozy in this set. You can’t go wrong with cashmere and I could wear the vest in September and add the cardigan on top in October.” — Sierra Mayhew, associate fashion editor

“Here’s your sign not to overlook J.Crew’s Collection items. They’re often a touch more forward and this beautiful semi-sheer skirt is a perfect example. It’s the kind of piece that feels very ‘fashion girl’ while still being wearable.” — Anna LaPlaca, editor

“This minimalist bucket bag shape is going to be everywhere this fall.” — Allyson Payer, senior fashion editor

“The covered buttons on this vest make it look crazy expensive.” — Allyson Payer, senior fashion editor

“I don’t usually wear a lot of color in the fall, but J.Crew is tempting me.” — Allyson Payer, senior fashion editor

“A good ankle boot is a must-buy for fall and these ones are exactly the kind I was looking for. I love that these have just the smallest heel, making them easy to wear on a busy day without hurting my feet. These also look like they pair perfectly with straight-leg jeans.” — Grace OConnell-Joshua, assistant shopping editor

“This jacket is just dripping in old money vibes. I’ll take two.” — Grace OConnell-Joshua, assistant shopping editor

“One thing I was most excited for with J.Crew’s creative revamp is the return of their signature rollneck knits—this sleeveless one is incredibly chic.” — Jennifer Camp Forbes, shopping updates editor

“I can’t stop wearing boxy jackets like this with everything from skirts to denim shorts. That will only continue into the fall with this luxe tweed iteration.” — Anna LaPlaca, editor

The roomier cut is fantastic.

This sweater set is so dreamy.

Can’t go wrong here.

A sleek pair of jeans.

The buttons!

A good belt is a must.

You’ll get so much wear out of this turtleneck.

Chic. Period.

Bring polish to any look.

Elegant trousers.

Adore this color.

Wow.

Absolutely beautiful.

Easy with jeans.

Make that statement.