Growing up in the famously overcast Pacific Northwest, I admittedly put very little thought toward protecting my melanin-blessed skin from the sun’s harsh rays. This could be because I once believed the wildly inaccurate (yet heavily perpetuated) idea that dark skin tones are at low risk for sun damage and other harsh environmental aggressors. Luckily, once I entered young adulthood and began taking better care of myself, I invested time and energy into discovering helpful everyday products. As you may have already guessed, identifying and investing in the right sunscreen was at the top of my list.

As a beauty editor, I regularly come into contact with hundreds of highly rated products marketed as must-haves. But it’s hearing from experts that has had the biggest impact on my shopping habits. For a better idea of where to start when making my sunscreen selections, I spoke to dermatologist Gary Goldfaden, MD, the co-founder of Goldfaden MD. The brand is known for its holistic-based and technologically advanced skincare solutions. It offers products that tackle several concerns, including dull complexions, uneven tone, and fine lines. If you’re itching to learn more about sunscreen and get your hands on the best ones, you’ll want to keep reading.

Did you know different sunscreens can address different skin concerns when used correctly? That’s right, I’m talking mineral and chemical sunscreen, both of which come in easy-to-apply sunscreen stick form. According to Goldfaden, mineral sunscreens contain physical blocking ingredients such as zinc or titanium oxide, which sit on the skin’s surface to build a protective barrier from harmful UV and UVB rays. They work immediately upon application and are ideal for individuals with skin sensitivity. Chemical sunscreens, on the other hand, may prove to be more irritating for some skin types but contain an effective medley of ingredients that absorb the rays.

One of the other biggest differences between the two can be found in the contact or lack thereof between the skin and the sunscreen of your choice. While chemical sunscreens use ingredients to absorb UV rays, they also allow for those same rays to touch and reach the skin. “These ingredients absorb the harmful UV rays but have been shown to be reproductive disruptors in some studies,” says Goldfaden. Mineral sunscreens contain non-toxic ingredients that physically block and deflect.

In Goldfaden’s opinion, mineral sunscreens have been proven to be more effective than their counterparts. His favorite is Mini Bloom’s Sunny Stick, an SPF 30 Mineral Sunscreen. With this in mind, I’ve gathered 17 of the best sunscreen sticks according to thousands of reviews. Believe me: They’re so good you’ll want to try a few of these out yourself.

This mineral sunscreen stick applies easily and dries sheer for a white cast-free finish. Customer review: “I’ve been on the hunt for a mineral-based sunscreen to use around my eyes for a while and decided to give this one a shot. It’s a small package, but [it] worked perfectly for what I needed and didn’t leave a white cast nor burn my very sensitive eyes. I use retinol eye cream, so I need an effective yet gentle sunscreen to use daily, and this little gem is fantastic! 10/10 recommend!” Pro: Very affordable price point. Con: None

Here’s a lightweight sunscreen stick that delivers powerful mineral protection against damaging UV rays. Customer review: “Everyone needs a sunscreen stick because it is just the most convenient product ever because reapplication of sunscreen is the most important thing. This one goes on smoothly, doesn’t have a white cast, and is mineral SPF 40. I love it.” Pro: Portable, twist-up stick applicator. Con: Not entirely sheer on deep skin tones

This Shiseido sunscreen stick is renowned for its non-greasy formula and glowy finish. Customer review: “I’ve been using the Shiseido Sunscreen Stick for a few months now, and I’m really happy with it. It’s clear, so it doesn’t leave a white cast on my skin, and it’s lightweight and non-greasy. It’s also easy to apply. I like that it’s waterproof and sweat-resistant, so I can use it on my face and body without worrying about it coming off.” Pro: Waterproof and sweat-resistant formula. Con: Shifts beneath makeup

Hundreds of five-star reviews reveal how quick and easy this Live Tinted sunscreen is to use on the go. Customer review: “I have always used face sunblock in a stick form because it seems to stay out of my eyes best. This one is the best I’ve ever used! The clear formula goes on so well it’s like putting on a serum. No dragging on the skin; it just glides extremely well. It has a tackiness to it after being applied. I think it would be great under makeup like a primer.” Pro: Purse-friendly size for easy reapplication. Con: Semi-sticky formula

Not only will this product’s minimalistic packaging look amazing on your vanity, but its formula is incredibly effective. Customer review: “I really like this sunscreen stick. It’s the perfect size to pop in the purse, and the rollup design makes it super easy to apply. The formulation is smooth and light and glides on easily without pulling. The tint is barely there, so it’s not too dark for my super fair skin, yet [it] doesn’t leave that dreaded zinc white cast. This stuff really seems invisible once it’s on.” Pro: Clean, all-natural formula. Con: Sunscreen is not easily applied to the skin using a stick applicator

Customer review: “Small, compact, easy to tuck into your back pocket! Easy to apply, [with] no smell and no heavy residue! Used throughout summer months here in sunny CA, and no negative skin reaction! Will be purchasing again when my supply runs low!” Pro: Offers all-mineral protection from environmental aggressors. Con: High price point

If you ask a WWW beauty editor for their holy grail sunscreen, there’s a good chance it will be this. Customer review: “I can see this lasting long. It’s easy to apply on my face and neck. This also doesn’t break me out, which is great. I can only use very few sunscreens due to my sensitive skin, and I’m glad to add this to the portfolio. It doesn’t leave that much of a white cast compared to other sunscreens, so I would say this is brown girl friendly.” Pro: Noncomedogenic formula. Con: Difficult to apply evenly and smoothly

Aveeno’s aptly named Protect + Soothe Mineral Sunscreen protects skin using mineral zinc oxide. Customer review: “I’ve always loved Aveeno products and looked forward to trying this stick. It had a slight smell when first applied but disappeared quickly. I loved how easy the stick was to apply. It made my skin feel soft after rubbing in a bit, and my skin still felt soft after washing it off. I wore this all day hiking in the bright sun (reapplying as needed) and has no burn on my face or arms.” Pro: Gentle on sensitive skin. Con: Leaves a white cast

Glossier’s bestselling sunscreen is incredibly lightweight with minimal fragrance. Customer review: “I’ve had this for probably a month now and love it. It’s definitely invisible, and the formula feels great on—like a light moisturizer. I have combination skin. Leaves my skin with a nice glow. Not too shiny.” Pro: Lightweight and easy to apply. Con: Not ideal for sensitive skin

I’ll use this face sunscreen all summer for sun protection that stays put and lasts all day. Customer review: “Love this. I have vitiligo, and when I’m in the sun, I put it on my hands, which are the worst spots, and it stays on all day, unlike others that you have to reapply and still don’t block the sun good [sic] enough. Plus, it’s small for my purse to take with me in case I end up in the sun and don’t plan on it.” Pro: Does not shift beneath makeup. Con: Difficult to apply evenly and smoothly

The Abib Sunstick Protection Bar is full of skin-loving ingredients such as acacia peptide, ceramide, and cucumber extract. Customer review: “If making a habit of wearing sunscreen feels like a chore you dread slathering on creams that feel heavy or sticky, then you need to buy this stick. Besides being kind of fun to apply, it has a lovely texture; it isn’t oily or thick. It goes on clear and has a unique shape that helps the stick to glide along the various contours of your face.” Pro: Soothing and moisturizing. Con: Limited amount of product (small in size)

This tinted mineral sunscreen is a must-have for sensitive and acne-prone skin. Customer review: “I use a stronger SPF on my face than my body, so my face is always paler. So I like to use tinted sunscreen to give my face a little color. We were traveling, and this product was in a stick form, which was preferable to a liquid [that] could leak. I was very happy with the ease of application/blending, the color tone, and the finish (not shiny). I wore it in very strong sunlight and did not burn.” Pro: Extremely moisturizing. Con: Somewhat oily finish

Throw this sunscreen stick in your bag to protect your skin against UV rays and other environmental aggressors. Customer review: “So, I recently purchased this sunscreen, and today was the first day I put it on, and so far, I’m loving it! I wore it with no makeup to see how it feels on my skin. It glides on easily, isn’t greasy, and makes my skin super soft. I have combination skin, and it doesn’t make me any more oily than I already am. I was really surprised at how soft it makes my skin feel.” Pro: Smooth and easy application. Con: None

Consider bringing this Neutrogena sunscreen stick with you on your next major trip to give your skin well-deserved TLC. Customer review: “If you’re headed to a sunny destination, and you’re only packing a carry-on (as enough liquid sunscreen would need to be in a checked bag), this sunscreen stick will hold up head to toe for multiple applications and multiple days. The sunscreen is lightweight on the skin, especially on the face. Just apply and rub in as normal.” Pro: Applies smoothly to the skin. Con: Leaves white residue

This sunscreen will ensure healthy and happy skin for the person perpetually on the move. Customer review: “Bought this on a whim just to try, and it was so worth it! It goes on so buttery soft, and it blends perfectly with makeup. It feels like a primer. I was worried it might feel too oily (over my oily skin), but even after a long day of work, it was actually less oily than when I don’t wear it! 10/10.” Pro: Formulated with olive oil extract. Con: Not lightweight or long wearing

Bare Republic’s Mineral Sunscreen stick is free of ingredients harmful to our environment. Customer review: “I like the Spirit sunscreen stick. It’s very easy to apply sunscreen, especially if you [are] kind of in a hurry. I like the SPF, and I also like that all Bare Republics sunscreens have a natural formula as well. I’ve been trying to find sunscreens that don’t use any kind of chemicals, and bare republic doesn’t use any chemicals in any of their sunscreens.” Pro: Environmentally friendly. Con: None

If you’re looking for a sunscreen that smells and feels amazing, give Coola’s Classic Organic Sunscreen Stick SPF 30 a try. Customer review: “I bought this to spot-cover some places that need extra sun protection, and it did not disappoint! I love the scent, texture, packability, and sheerness of the cover. Another gold star product from Coola!” Pro: Light enough for everyday use. Con: Visibly oily finish

Up next, Dry Skin? Don’t Apply Your Foundation Without One of These Hydrating Primers